Survival Actions vs. Wrongful Death Lawsuits: Can You Do Both?

The tragic loss of a loved one due to someone else's negligence can lead to complex legal proceedings, primarily through survival actions and wrongful death claims. Understanding the distinctions and similarities between these two legal avenues is crucial for ensuring justice and obtaining the appropriate compensation. This detailed article delves into the intricacies of survival actions versus wrongful death claims, analyzing their similarities and differences to provide a comprehensive guide for navigating these challenging legal battles.

Similarities Between Survival Actions and Wrongful Death Claims

  1. Purpose of Compensation

    • Seeking Justice: Both survival actions and wrongful death claims aim to seek justice for the deceased. These legal actions hold the responsible party accountable for their negligence or misconduct that led to the death.

    • Compensation for Damages: Both actions are designed to provide financial compensation for the damages incurred as a result of the wrongful act. This includes covering medical expenses, loss of income, and other associated costs.

  2. Legal Basis

    • Negligence or Misconduct: Both types of claims are rooted in proving that the death was caused by another party's negligence or intentional misconduct. Establishing this fault is essential for the success of either legal action.

    • Burden of Proof: In both cases, the burden of proof lies with the plaintiff, who must demonstrate that the defendant's actions directly led to the death of the deceased.

  3. Statutory Framework

    • State-Specific Laws: Both survival actions and wrongful death claims are governed by state laws, which define the eligibility, procedures, and limitations for filing such claims. Understanding the specific statutes in the relevant state is crucial for pursuing these actions effectively.

    • Filing Deadlines: Both types of claims are subject to statutory deadlines, known as statutes of limitations. These deadlines dictate the timeframe within which the legal action must be initiated.

  4. Role of the Estate

    • Representation by the Estate: In both survival actions and wrongful death claims, the deceased's estate often plays a central role. The personal representative or executor of the estate may file the claim on behalf of the deceased and their beneficiaries.

    • Distribution of Compensation: The compensation awarded in both types of claims is typically distributed among the deceased's beneficiaries or heirs, according to state laws and the terms of the deceased's will.

  5. Types of Recoverable Damages

    • Economic Damages: Both survival actions and wrongful death claims can seek economic damages such as medical expenses incurred before death, funeral and burial costs, and loss of income or financial support.

    • Non-Economic Damages: Both actions may also pursue non-economic damages, including pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of companionship.

Differences Between Survival Actions and Wrongful Death Claims

  1. Nature of the Claim

    • Survival Actions: Survival actions continue the personal injury claim that the deceased would have had if they had survived. These claims focus on the damages the deceased suffered from the time of the injury until their death.

    • Wrongful Death Claims: Wrongful death claims are initiated by the deceased's beneficiaries to compensate for their losses resulting from the death. These claims address the impact of the death on the surviving family members.

  2. Claimants

    • Survival Actions: The personal representative or executor of the deceased's estate typically files survival actions on behalf of the deceased. The claim is brought by the estate itself.

    • Wrongful Death Claims: These claims are filed by the deceased's surviving family members, such as the spouse, children, or parents. The family members seek compensation for their personal losses due to the death.

  3. Damages Focus

    • Survival Actions: The damages in survival actions focus on the deceased's pain and suffering, medical expenses, and lost wages from the time of the injury until death. The goal is to compensate the deceased for their own experiences and losses.

    • Wrongful Death Claims: Wrongful death claims focus on the financial and emotional losses suffered by the surviving family members. This includes loss of financial support, companionship, guidance, and emotional suffering.

  4. Beneficiaries

    • Survival Actions: The compensation awarded in survival actions becomes part of the deceased's estate and is distributed according to the will or state intestacy laws. The beneficiaries are those who inherit from the estate.

    • Wrongful Death Claims: The beneficiaries in wrongful death claims are the surviving family members who have suffered a direct loss due to the death. The distribution of compensation is based on the relationship to the deceased and the extent of their losses.

  5. Calculation of Damages

    • Survival Actions: Damages in survival actions are calculated based on the deceased's suffering and financial losses before their death. This includes medical bills, pain and suffering, and lost wages during the period they lived after the injury.

    • Wrongful Death Claims: Damages in wrongful death claims are calculated based on the financial and emotional impact on the surviving family members. This includes loss of income, future earnings, benefits, and the emotional toll of losing a loved one.

Conclusion

Navigating the legal landscape of survival actions and wrongful death claims requires a thorough understanding of their similarities and differences. Both types of claims seek to provide justice and compensation for the deceased and their families, but they do so through distinct legal mechanisms. By recognizing the unique aspects of each claim, families can make informed decisions and work effectively with legal professionals to secure the maximum compensation for their losses.

Share